Mark Gastineau Confronts Brett Favre Over 'Dive' That Cost Him NFL Sack Record
For 22 years, Mark Gastineau’s name stood atop the NFL record books for the most sacks in a single season. His 1984 season with the New York Jets was a masterclass in defensive dominance, tallying 22 sacks—a record that seemed untouchable. But in 2001, that record was broken in controversial fashion when Michael Strahan of the New York Giants recorded his 22.5th sack, courtesy of what many believed was a “gift” from Green Bay Packers quarterback Brett Favre.
Now, over two decades later, Gastineau has confronted Favre, accusing him of “taking a dive” on the record-breaking play that has remained a sore spot for many fans of the game.
The Controversial Play
The moment in question occurred during a Week 17 matchup in the 2001 NFL season. With Strahan just half a sack shy of breaking the record, Brett Favre rolled out on a play and appeared to deliberately slide down in front of the onrushing Strahan, giving him the historic sack.
To many observers, the play looked more like a scripted handoff than an organic football moment. Critics accused Favre of intentionally helping his friend Strahan secure the record, tarnishing what should have been a monumental achievement.
Gastineau, known for his fiery personality, has never shied away from expressing his disdain for the play. For years, he remained vocal about his belief that the integrity of the record was compromised.
Gastineau Confronts Favre
In a recent interview, Gastineau revealed that he finally had the chance to confront Favre about the play. The interaction, described as intense but civil, saw Gastineau directly ask Favre why he "took a dive." According to Gastineau, Favre didn’t deny it outright but instead deflected, saying it was “just part of the game.”
Gastineau shared his frustration:
"That record was something I worked my entire career for. To see it broken that way, it hurt. And I told Brett that. It wasn’t earned on the field—it was handed over."
While Favre has consistently denied any wrongdoing, his body language during the play and the lack of any defensive resistance on his part have continued to fuel speculation.
The Legacy of the Record
The debate over the legitimacy of Strahan’s record has overshadowed what should have been a celebration of his incredible season. Strahan was undoubtedly dominant in 2001, leading the NFL in sacks and wreaking havoc on opposing quarterbacks. Yet, the nature of the record-breaking play left a blemish that neither Strahan nor Favre have been able to fully shake off.
For Gastineau, the controversy goes beyond personal disappointment. He believes it set a dangerous precedent, questioning whether future records might also be achieved through staged plays rather than genuine competition.
"It’s not just about me," Gastineau explained. "It’s about respecting the game and the effort it takes to achieve greatness. Records are meant to be broken, but they’re also meant to be earned."
Public Reaction and Debate
Gastineau’s confrontation with Favre reignited a debate among fans and analysts. Some argue that Strahan deserves credit for his incredible season, regardless of how the final sack unfolded. Others side with Gastineau, believing that records should reflect the purity of competition and not be tainted by questionable plays.
Social media lit up with commentary following Gastineau’s interview. Some fans criticized him for holding onto the grudge, while others applauded him for standing up for the integrity of the game.
Looking Forward
Gastineau’s single-season sack record might no longer stand, but his impact on the game remains undeniable. He was one of the most electrifying pass rushers of his era, revolutionizing the way defensive linemen attacked quarterbacks.
As for Strahan, his Hall of Fame career and charismatic presence in the media have cemented his legacy, even as the controversy lingers. And Brett Favre? His role in the saga will likely remain a point of contention among NFL historians and fans alike.
Ultimately, this story is a reminder of the passion and intensity that records evoke—not just among players but within the broader football community. While the debate over Strahan’s record may never be fully resolved, one thing is clear: Mark Gastineau’s contribution to the game will always be respected, even as the record books tell a different story.
What’s your take on the controversial play? Should Strahan’s record count, or does Gastineau have a point? Let us know in the comments below!
Check out The Video
