Where to Find Top Baseball Prospects Cards in 2025: Best Products & Market Trends
Baseball America has released its highly anticipated updated Top 100 Prospects list as we gear up for the 2025 season. The list highlights a mix of elite hitters and pitchers, with the AL East dominating the top spots. Four of the Top 10 prospects have already debuted in the MLB, making their cards even more enticing for collectors. Here’s a breakdown of the top 10 prospects, their standout products, and the best places to find their cards.
1. Roman Anthony (Boston Red Sox – OF)
Top Cards:
2023 Bowman (1st Bowman)
2023 Bowman Chrome
2023 Bowman Draft
2023 Bowman Sapphire (1st Bowman)
2023 Bowman’s Best
2024 Bowman Sapphire
2024 Topps Pro Debut
Bio: At 6’2” and 200 lbs., this lefty outfielder has rapidly climbed the minors, amassing a .291 batting average, 18 home runs, and 65 RBIs in 2024. As a AAA standout, Anthony could debut in Boston early this season. Best Places: eBay, high-profile auctions, and Boston card shows.
2. Jackson Jobe (Detroit Tigers – RHP)
Top Cards:
2021 Bowman Draft (1st Bowman)
2021 Bowman Chrome Draft Sapphire (1st Bowman)
2022 Bowman line of products
2023 Panini Elite Extra Edition
Bio: The Tigers’ top pitching prospect dazzled in 2024, earning a 2.36 ERA across 91.2 innings. Jobe debuted in the majors late in the season, adding intrigue to his 2021 Bowman Draft cards. Best Places: eBay, Tigers fan events, and COMC.
3. Dylan Crews (Washington Nationals – OF)
Top Cards:
2024 Bowman (1st Bowman)
2024 Bowman Chrome
2024 Bowman Sapphire (1st Bowman)
2024 Topps Pro Debut
Bio: The 2023 second overall pick had an impressive first MLB stint, showcasing speed and power with 3 HRs and 12 steals in limited time. Crews’ all-star potential makes him a collector’s dream. Best Places: Facebook breaks, Nationals’ memorabilia shops, and eBay.
4. Chase Dollander (Colorado Rockies – RHP)
Top Cards:
2023 Leaf Metal
2023 Panini Elite Extra Edition
2024 Panini Prizm
Bio: The 6’2” righty struck out 169 batters in 118 innings in 2024. Despite concerns about pitching at Coors Field, Dollander’s potential to shine keeps his cards in demand. Best Places: Local card shops, Rockies events, and Panini-exclusive platforms.
5. Jasson Dominguez (New York Yankees – OF)
Top Cards:
2020 Bowman Chrome Sapphire (1st Bowman)
2024 Topps Chrome (rookie)
2024 Bowman Sterling
Bio: Known as “The Martian,” Dominguez’s blend of speed and power has kept collectors intrigued since his 2020 Bowman debut. A strong spring could make him a 2025 Yankees starter. Best Places: eBay, Yankees fan forums, and card shows in NYC.
6. Walker Jenkins (Minnesota Twins – OF)
Top Cards:
2024 Bowman (1st Bowman)
2024 Bowman Chrome
2024 Bowman Sapphire (1st Bowman)
Bio: The Twins’ promising 19-year-old hit .302 with 9 HRs and 23 steals in 2024. Jenkins’ cards, especially his Bowman 1st editions, are a must for serious collectors. Best Places: Target/Walmart for unopened packs, and Minnesota-area shops.
7. Carson Williams (Tampa Bay Rays – SS)
Top Cards:
2021 Bowman Draft (1st Bowman)
2021 Bowman Draft Sapphire
2024 Bowman Chrome
Bio: The power-hitting shortstop has slugged 62 career minor league homers, putting him on the cusp of the majors. Best Places: Florida-based card shows and eBay.
8. Coby Mayo (Baltimore Orioles – 3B)
Top Cards:
2021 Bowman (1st Bowman)
2021 Bowman Sterling
2024 Panini Donruss
Bio: Mayo’s raw power and minor league success have collectors watching closely. With a chance to solidify a spot in Baltimore’s lineup, his cards are heating up. Best Places: Orioles spring training events, and eBay.
9. Noah Schultz (Chicago White Sox – LHP)
Top Cards:
2022 Bowman Draft (1st Bowman)
2022 Bowman Draft Sapphire (1st Bowman)
2024 Panini Donruss
Bio: The 6’9” southpaw pitched to a 2.03 ERA in 2024, evoking comparisons to Randy Johnson. Schultz’s Bowman cards are becoming harder to find. Best Places: Chicago-area shows and high-end grading services.
10. Marcelo Mayer (Boston Red Sox – SS)
Top Cards:
2021 Bowman Draft (1st Bowman)
2024 Bowman line of products
2024 Topps Pro Debut
Bio: The smooth-fielding Mayer hit .285 in AAA last season, and his MLB debut is imminent. His Bowman 1st cards remain cornerstone collectibles. Best Places: Boston memorabilia shops, eBay, and major card shows.
Key Market Trends for Collectors in 2025
Increased Demand for Graded Cards: Cards graded by PSA, BGS, and SGC are fetching higher premiums.
Focus on Sapphire Parallels: Sapphire editions, especially from Bowman, are highly sought after for their rarity.
Rise of Prospect Breaks: Online card breaks focused on Bowman Draft and Chrome products are gaining popularity.
By staying informed about products and market trends, you can position yourself to find the best cards of baseball’s brightest stars. Happy collecting!
